If you're reading this, there's a good chance your kid just cracked their phone screen. Or they cracked it last month and you fixed it, and now it's cracked again. Welcome to the club.
Here's the reality: the average kid breaks a phone screen every 12 to 18 months. We see it constantly at our shop. Phones get dropped on playground concrete, sat on during soccer practice, knocked off bunk beds, and shoved into backpacks with textbooks. It's not carelessness — it's being a kid.
The good news is you don't have to spend a fortune dealing with it. This guide covers what actually works: the right cases, the right insurance decisions, when to repair vs. replace, and how to teach your kid to take care of their stuff without losing your mind.
A $20-40 case is the single best investment you can make for a kid's phone. It's cheaper than one repair, and it prevents most of them. Here's what we recommend from seeing hundreds of cracked phones come through the shop:
The math is simple: $15-40 for a case vs. $100-200 for a screen repair. Every parent who brings in a caseless cracked phone says the same thing: "I know, I should have gotten a case." Get the case.
A case protects against drops. A screen protector protects against scratches and flat-surface impacts. For kids, you need both — but only if you get the right kind.
Pro tip: buy tempered glass protectors in bulk. A 3-pack from brands like Spigen or amFilm runs about $10. When one cracks (and it will), peel it off, slap on a new one, and move on. That's the system working as designed.
Every carrier and manufacturer offers device insurance, and on the surface it sounds reasonable. But let's run the numbers:
Now compare that to just paying for repairs as they happen:
Even if your kid cracks the screen twice in two years, you'd pay $158-298 in repairs — less than most insurance plans cost in premiums alone, before the deductible.
Insurance makes sense in one scenario: total loss (theft, water submersion, or completely destroyed phone) on a brand-new flagship device. For routine kid damage — cracked screens, busted charging ports, dented back glass — you're better off paying out of pocket.
Here's what we repair most often on kids' phones, in order:
Most of these repairs take under an hour. A cracked screen doesn't mean you need a new phone — it means you need a $79-149 repair and a better case.
Here's something most parents don't consider: giving a kid an $800+ flagship phone is like handing them $800 cash and hoping they don't lose it.
A quality refurbished phone costs $150-300 and does everything a kid needs — social media, messaging, photos, YouTube, and games. An iPhone 13 or Samsung Galaxy S22 in refurbished condition runs about $200-280 and will last another 3-4 years with proper care.
Benefits of the refurbished route:
Here's a simple test: Would you trust your kid with $200 in cash? If the answer is no — if you think they'd lose it, leave it somewhere, or not take care of it — then don't give them an $800 phone without protection.
Get them a solid case, a tempered glass protector, and either a refurbished phone or keep a tight grip on that insurance deductible. Match the phone to the responsibility level, not the wish list.
Rule: The phone lives in one spot when not in use. Designate a charging station. The phone goes there when they're home. No carrying it around the house, no leaving it on the couch, no taking it to the bathroom. Build the habit of putting it in a specific place every single time.
Rule: Two hands or a pocket. Nothing else. If they're using the phone, both hands. If they're not, it goes in a front pocket — never a back pocket (that's how phones get sat on), never carried loosely, never set down on random surfaces. If the case comes off for any reason, the phone doesn't leave the house until the case is back on.
Rule: You break it, you pay part of it. Split repair costs — you cover 50-75%, they cover the rest from allowance, birthday money, or chores. Nothing teaches careful handling faster than paying $40 toward your own screen replacement. By 16, they should be handling the case and protector purchases themselves.
Rule: You break it, you fix it. By this age, they should own the repair decision. Bring them to the shop, let them talk through the options, and let them pay. They'll take care of the next phone a lot better when they've experienced the real cost of not doing so.
Kids break phones. That's not going to change. What you can control is how much it costs you when it happens:
Kid crack their screen again?
Bring it in. Most kid-damage repairs are done same day — screens, charging ports, back glass. Free quote, 90-day warranty, and we'll help you pick a case that'll survive the next drop.
Get a Free QuoteWhich phone cases actually protect against drops? We've seen hundreds of cracked phones — here's what works.
Read article →A practical guide to deciding whether to repair a cracked screen or buy a new phone.
Read article →How to spot a good deal and avoid buying someone else's problem.
Read article →